Merge branch 'main' into docs/studio

how_to/004_tags.luau

@@ -16,8 +16,8 @@ local jecs = require("@jecs")
 --[[
 	There are two ways to create tags:
 
-	1. Using jecs.tag() - preregister a tag entity which will be allocated when you create the world.
+	1. Using jecs.tag() to preregister a tag entity which will be allocated when you create the world.
-	2. Using world:entity() - creates a regular entity id
+	2. Using world:entity() to create a regular entity id
 
 	The first method is the "proper" way to create tags but it hinges upon that
 	you do remember to create the world after declaring all of your

how_to/022_query_caching.luau

@@ -79,6 +79,6 @@ end
 -- Cached query (faster for repeated use)
 local cached_query = world:query(Position, Velocity):cached()
 for entity, pos, vel in cached_query do
-	-- Process entities - this is faster for repeated iterations
+	-- Process entities. This is faster for repeated iterations.
 end
 

how_to/110_hooks.luau

@@ -17,8 +17,9 @@ world:set(Transform, jecs.OnAdd, function(entity, id, data)
 	print(`Transform added to entity {entity}`)
 end)
 
-world:set(Transform, jecs.OnRemove, function(entity, id)
+world:set(Transform, jecs.OnRemove, function(entity, id, delete)
 	-- A transform component id has been removed from entity
+	-- delete is true if the entity is being deleted, false/nil otherwise
 	print(`Transform removed from entity {entity}`)
 end)
 
@@ -38,3 +39,66 @@ end)
 	When an entity graph contains cycles, order is undefined. This includes cycles
 	that can be formed using different relationships.
 ]]
+
+--[[
+	Structural changes in OnRemove hooks
+
+	You can call world:add, world:remove, and world:set inside OnRemove hooks.
+	That's fine. But there's a catch.
+
+	When an entity is being deleted, all of its components get removed. Each
+	removal triggers the OnRemove hook. If you try to make structural changes
+	to the entity during deletion, like removing more components or adding new
+	ones, you're fighting against the deletion process itself. The entity is
+	going to lose all its components anyway, so what's the point?
+
+	This creates a conflict. On one hand, you might want to clean up related
+	components when a specific component is removed. On the other hand, during
+	deletion, you don't want to do that because the entity is already being
+	torn down. So you need a way to tell the difference.
+
+	The solution is the delete boolean. Every OnRemove hook receives it as the
+	third parameter. It's true when the entity is being deleted, and false
+	(or nil) when you're just removing a single component normally.
+
+	So you check it. If delete is true, you bail out early. If it's false,
+	you do your cleanup. Simple.
+
+	Here's what it looks like in practice:
+]]
+
+local Health = world:component()
+local Dead = world:component()
+
+world:set(Health, jecs.OnRemove, function(entity, id, delete)
+	if delete then
+		-- Entity is being deleted, don't try to clean up
+		return
+	end
+
+	-- Normal removal, do cleanup
+	world:remove(entity, Dead)
+end)
+
+--[[
+	The ob.luau module uses this pattern extensively. When you're building
+	observers or monitors that track component removals, you need to distinguish
+	between "component removed" and "entity deleted" because they mean different
+	things for your tracking logic.
+
+	Now, about the DEBUG flag. If you create a world with DEBUG enabled:
+
+		local world = jecs.world(true)
+
+	Then the world will actively prevent you from calling world:add, world:remove,
+	or world:set inside OnRemove hooks when delete is true. It throws an error
+	that tells you exactly what went wrong. This is useful during development
+	to catch cases where you forgot to check the delete flag.
+
+	But here's the important part: even with DEBUG enabled, you're still allowed
+	to call these functions when delete is false. The DEBUG mode only prevents
+	structural changes during deletion, not during normal component removal.
+
+	So the pattern is always the same: check delete, bail if true, proceed if false.
+	The DEBUG flag just makes sure you don't forget to do the check.
+]]

modules/ob.luau

@@ -83,6 +83,9 @@ local function observers_new(
 				local tgt = jecs.ECS_PAIR_SECOND(term)
 				local wc = tgt == jecs.w
 				local onremoved = world:removed(rel, function(entity, id, delete: boolean?)
+					if delete then
+						return
+					end
 					if not wc and id ~= term then
 						return
 					end
@@ -98,7 +101,10 @@ local function observers_new(
 
 				table.insert(cleanup, onremoved)
 			else
-				local onremoved = world:removed(term, function(entity, id)
+				local onremoved = world:removed(term, function(entity, id, delete: boolean?)
+					if delete then
+						return
+					end
 					local r = jecs.record(world, entity)
 					local archetype = r.archetype
 					if archetype then

rokit.toml

@@ -1,5 +1,5 @@
 [tools]
 wally = "upliftgames/wally@0.3.2"
-rojo = "rojo-rbx/rojo@7.4.4"
+rojo = "rojo-rbx/rojo@7.7.0-rc.1"
-luau = "luau-lang/luau@0.701"
+luau = "luau-lang/luau@0.703.0"
-zune = "scythe-technology/zune@0.5.1"
+zune = "scythe-technology/zune@0.5.1"

src/jecs.d.ts

@@ -121,7 +121,7 @@ export class World {
 	/**
 	 * Creates a new World.
 	 */
-	private constructor();
+	private constructor(DEBUG?: boolean);
 
 	/**
 	 * Enforces a check for entities to be created within a desired range.
@@ -354,9 +354,9 @@ export type ComponentRecord = {
 export function component_record(world: World, id: Id): ComponentRecord;
 
 type TagToUndefined<T> = T extends TagDiscriminator ? undefined : T
-type TrimOptional<T extends unknown[]> = T extends [...infer L, infer R] 
+type TrimOptional<T extends unknown[]> = T extends [...infer L, infer R]
-	? unknown extends R 
+	? unknown extends R
-		? L | T | TrimOptional<L> 
+		? L | T | TrimOptional<L>
 		: R extends undefined
 			? L | T | TrimOptional<L>
 			: T

test/benches/default.project.json

@@ -12,16 +12,16 @@
 		"ReplicatedStorage": {
 			"$className": "ReplicatedStorage",
 			"Lib": {
-				"$path": "../src/jecs.luau"
+				"$path": "../../src/jecs.luau"
 			},
 			"benches": {
-				"$path": "benches"
+				"$path": "visual"
 			},
 			"mirror": {
-				"$path": "mirror.luau"
+				"$path": "../../src/mirror.luau"
 			},
 			"DevPackages": {
-				"$path": "benches/visual/DevPackages"
+				"$path": "visual/DevPackages"
 			}
 		}
 	}

test/benches/query.luau

@@ -27,48 +27,11 @@ do
 			G: jecs.Id,
 			H: jecs.Id
 		)
-			BENCH("1 component", function()
-				for _ in world:query(A) do
-				end
-			end)
-
-			BENCH("2 component", function()
-				for _ in world:query(B, A) do
-				end
-			end)
-
 			BENCH("4 component", function()
 				for _ in world:query(D, C, B, A) do
 				end
 			end)
 
-			BENCH("8 component", function()
-				for _ in world:query(H, G, F, E, D, C, B, A) do
-				end
-			end)
-
-			local e = world:entity()
-			world:set(e, A, true)
-			world:set(e, B, true)
-			world:set(e, C, true)
-			world:set(e, D, true)
-			world:set(e, E, true)
-			world:set(e, F, true)
-			world:set(e, G, true)
-			world:set(e, H, true)
-
-			BENCH("Update Data", function()
-				for _ = 1, 100 do
-					world:set(e, A, false)
-					world:set(e, B, false)
-					world:set(e, C, false)
-					world:set(e, D, false)
-					world:set(e, E, false)
-					world:set(e, F, false)
-					world:set(e, G, false)
-					world:set(e, H, false)
-				end
-			end)
 		end
 
 		local D1 = ecs:component()
@@ -86,8 +49,9 @@ do
 
 		local added = 0
 		local archetypes = {}
-		for i = 1, 2 ^ 16 - 2 do
+		for i = 1, 2 ^ 12 - 2 do
 			local entity = ecs:entity()
+			ecs:add(entity, entity)
 
 			local combination = ""
 
@@ -153,48 +117,10 @@ do
 			G: jecs.Id,
 			H: jecs.Id
 		)
-			BENCH("1 component", function()
-				for _ in world:query(A) do
-				end
-			end)
-
-			BENCH("2 component", function()
-				for _ in world:query(B, A) do
-				end
-			end)
-
 			BENCH("4 component", function()
 				for _ in world:query(D, C, B, A) do
 				end
 			end)
-
-			BENCH("8 component", function()
-				for _ in world:query(H, G, F, E, D, C, B, A) do
-				end
-			end)
-
-			local e = world:entity()
-			world:set(e, A, true)
-			world:set(e, B, true)
-			world:set(e, C, true)
-			world:set(e, D, true)
-			world:set(e, E, true)
-			world:set(e, F, true)
-			world:set(e, G, true)
-			world:set(e, H, true)
-
-			BENCH("Update Data", function()
-				for _ = 1, 100 do
-					world:set(e, A, false)
-					world:set(e, B, false)
-					world:set(e, C, false)
-					world:set(e, D, false)
-					world:set(e, E, false)
-					world:set(e, F, false)
-					world:set(e, G, false)
-					world:set(e, H, false)
-				end
-			end)
 		end
 
 		local D1 = ecs:component()
@@ -207,13 +133,14 @@ do
 		local D8 = ecs:component()
 
 		local function flip()
-			return math.random() >= 0.15
+			return math.random() >= 0.5
 		end
 
 		local added = 0
 		local archetypes = {}
-		for i = 1, 2 ^ 16 - 2 do
+		for i = 1, 2 ^ 12 - 2 do
 			local entity = ecs:entity()
+			ecs:add(entity, entity)
 
 			local combination = ""
 
@@ -246,11 +173,9 @@ do
 				ecs:set(entity, D8, { value = true })
 			end
 
-			if #combination == 7 then
+			if flip() then
-				added += 1
 				ecs:set(entity, D1, { value = true })
 			end
-			archetypes[combination] = true
 		end
 
 		local a = 0

test/benches/visual/query.bench.luau

@@ -50,85 +50,54 @@ local E8 = mcs:component()
 local registry2 = ecr.registry()
 
 local function flip()
-	return math.random() >= 0.25
+	return math.random() >= 0.5
 end
 
-local N = 2 ^ 16 - 2
+local N = 2 ^ 12- 2
 local archetypes = {}
 
 local hm = 0
 for i = 1, N do
-	local id = registry2.create()
-	local combination = ""
-	local n = newWorld:spawn()
 	local entity = ecs:entity()
 	local m = mcs:entity()
+	if flip() then
+		ecs:add(entity, entity)
+		mcs:add(m, m)
+	end
 
 	if flip() then
-		registry2:set(id, B1, { value = true })
-		ecs:set(entity, D1, { value = true })
-		newWorld:insert(n, A1({ value = true }))
 		mcs:set(m, E1, { value = 2 })
+		ecs:set(entity, D1, {value = true})
 	end
 	if flip() then
-		combination ..= "B"
-		registry2:set(id, B2, { value = true })
 		ecs:set(entity, D2, { value = true })
 		mcs:set(m, E2, { value = 2 })
-		newWorld:insert(n, A2({ value = true }))
 	end
 	if flip() then
-		combination ..= "C"
-		registry2:set(id, B3, { value = true })
 		ecs:set(entity, D3, { value = true })
 		mcs:set(m, E3, { value = 2 })
-		newWorld:insert(n, A3({ value = true }))
 	end
 	if flip() then
-		combination ..= "D"
-		registry2:set(id, B4, { value = true })
 		ecs:set(entity, D4, { value = true })
 		mcs:set(m, E4, { value = 2 })
-
-		newWorld:insert(n, A4({ value = true }))
 	end
 	if flip() then
-		combination ..= "E"
-		registry2:set(id, B5, { value = true })
 		ecs:set(entity, D5, { value = true })
 		mcs:set(m, E5, { value = 2 })
-
-		newWorld:insert(n, A5({ value = true }))
 	end
 	if flip() then
-		combination ..= "F"
-		registry2:set(id, B6, { value = true })
 		ecs:set(entity, D6, { value = true })
 		mcs:set(m, E6, { value = 2 })
-		newWorld:insert(n, A6({ value = true }))
 	end
 	if flip() then
-		combination ..= "G"
-		registry2:set(id, B7, { value = true })
 		ecs:set(entity, D7, { value = true })
 		mcs:set(m, E7, { value = 2 })
-		newWorld:insert(n, A7({ value = true }))
 	end
 	if flip() then
-		combination ..= "H"
-		registry2:set(id, B8, { value = true })
-		newWorld:insert(n, A8({ value = true }))
 		ecs:set(entity, D8, { value = true })
 		mcs:set(m, E8, { value = 2 })
 	end
 
-	if combination:find("BCDF") then
-		if not archetypes[combination] then
-			print(combination)
-		end
-		hm += 1
-	end
-	archetypes[combination] = true
 end
 print("TEST", hm)
 
@@ -140,30 +109,38 @@ end
 
 print(count)
 
+local mq = mcs:query(E1, E2, E3, E4)
+local jq = ecs:query(D1, D2, D3, D4)
+
 return {
 	ParameterGenerator = function()
 		return
 	end,
 
 	Functions = {
-		Matter = function()
+		-- Matter = function()
-			for entityId, firstComponent in newWorld:query(A2, A4, A6, A8) do
+		-- 	for entityId, firstComponent in newWorld:query(A2, A4, A6, A8) do
-			end
-		end,
-
-		ECR = function()
-			for entityId, firstComponent in registry2:view(B2, B4, B6, B8) do
-			end
-		end,
-
-		-- Mirror = function()
-		-- 	for entityId, firstComponent in mcs:query(E2, E4, E6, E8) do
 		-- 	end
 		-- end,
 
-		Jecs = function()
+		-- ECR = function()
-			for entityId, firstComponent in ecs:query(D2, D4, D6, D8) do
+		-- 	for entityId, firstComponent in registry2:view(B2, B4, B6, B8) do
+		-- 	end
+		-- end,
+
+		Mirror = function()
+			for i = 1, 10 do
+				for entityId, firstComponent in mq:iter() do
+				end
 			end
 		end,
+
+		Jecs = function()
+			for i = 1, 10 do
+				for entityId, firstComponent in jq:iter() do
+				end
+			end
+
+		end,
 	},
 }

test/tests.luau

@@ -24,83 +24,8 @@ type Id<T=unknown> = jecs.Id<T>
 local entity_visualiser = require("@modules/entity_visualiser")
 local dwi = entity_visualiser.stringify
 
-TEST("optimize idr_r removal", function()
-
-	local pair = jecs.pair
-    local world = jecs.world()
-    local rel = world:component()
-    local A = world:component()
-    local B = world:component()
-
-    local t1 = world:entity()
-    local t2 = world:entity()
-
-    local entities = {} :: { jecs.Entity }
-
-    for i = 1, 10 do
-
-	    local e1 = world:entity()
-        local e2 = world:entity()
-
-        world:set(e1, A, true)
-        world:set(e2, A, true)
-        world:add(e1, pair(B, t1))
-        world:add(e1, pair(B, t2))
-        world:add(e2, pair(B, t1))
-        world:add(e2, pair(B, t2))
-
-        table.insert(entities, e1)
-        table.insert(entities, e2)
-    end
-
-    local e1 = world:entity()
-    local e2 = world:entity()
-
-    table.insert(entities, e1)
-	table.insert(entities, e2)
-
-    world:set(e1, A, true)
-    world:set(e2, A, true)
-    world:add(e1, pair(B, t1))
-    world:add(e1, pair(B, t2))
-    world:add(e2, pair(B, t1))
-    world:add(e2, pair(B, t2))
-
-    BENCH("delete B", function()
-    	world:delete(B)
-    end)
-
-    for _, e in entities do
-	    CHECK(world:has(e, A))
-        CHECK(not world:target(e, B))
-        CHECK(not world:target(e, B))
-    end
-
-end)
-TEST("deleting t1's archetype before invoking its onremove hooks", function()
-    local pair = jecs.pair
-    local world = jecs.world()
-    local rel = world:component()
-
-    local t1 = world:entity()
-    local t2 = world:entity()
-
-    --[[
-    weirdly enough if i do this (only when adding childof relation after adding (rel, t2) to t1) it does not error. Probably a red herring
-
-    world:add(t2, pair(rel, t1))
-    world:add(t1, pair(rel, t2))
-    world:add(t2, pair(jecs.ChildOf, t1))
-    --]]
-
-    -- this causes world:delete to error
-    world:add(t2, pair(jecs.ChildOf, t1))
-    world:add(t1, pair(rel, t2))
-
-    world:delete(t1)
-end)
 TEST("reproduce idr_t nil archetype bug", function()
-	local world = jecs.world()
+	local world = jecs.world(true)
 
 	local cts = {
 	    Humanoid = world:component(),
@@ -121,46 +46,58 @@ TEST("reproduce idr_t nil archetype bug", function()
 	    local src = r.archetype
 
 	    --REMOVING THIS jecs.archetype_traverse_remove CALL STOPS IT FROM HAPPENING
-	    local dst = src and jecs.archetype_traverse_remove(world, id, src)
+		CHECK_EXPECT_ERR(function()
+			world:remove(entity, cts.Humanoid)
+		end)
 	end)
 
-	local batches = 10
+	local batchSize = 200
-	local batchSize = 20
 
 	local trackedEntities: { [number]: { parentId: number? } } = {}
 
-	for batch = 1, batches do
+    for i = 1, batchSize do
-	    for i = 1, batchSize do
-	        local root = world:entity()
-	        world:add(root, jecs.pair(jecs.ChildOf, char))
 
-	        -- Removing animator from trackEntity1 causes it to stop happening
+	    local root = world:entity()
-	        local trackEntity1 = world:entity()
+        -- world:add(root, jecs.pair(jecs.ChildOf, char))
-	        world:set(trackEntity1, cts.Animator, 0)
-	        world:add(trackEntity1, jecs.pair(jecs.ChildOf, root))
-	        trackedEntities[trackEntity1] = { parentId = root }
 
-	        -- Removing animator from trackEntity2 causes it to happen less frequently
+        -- Removing animator from trackEntity1 causes it to stop happening
-	        local trackEntity2 = world:entity()
+        local trackEntity1 = world:entity()
-	        world:set(trackEntity2, cts.Animator, 0)
+        world:set(trackEntity1, cts.Animator, 0)
-	        world:add(trackEntity2, jecs.pair(jecs.ChildOf, root))
+        world:add(trackEntity1, jecs.pair(jecs.ChildOf, root))
-	        trackedEntities[trackEntity2] = { parentId = root }
+        world:set(trackEntity1, jecs.Name, "trackEntity1v"..i)
+        trackedEntities[trackEntity1] = { parentId = root }
 
-	        -- Removing this, but keeping Animator on the other 2 causes it to stop happening
+        -- Removing animator from trackEntity2 causes it to happen less frequently
-	        world:set(trackEntity1, cts.VelocitizeAnimationWeight, 0)
+        local trackEntity2 = world:entity()
+        world:set(trackEntity2, cts.Animator, 0)
+        world:add(trackEntity2, jecs.pair(jecs.ChildOf, root))
+        world:set(trackEntity2, jecs.Name, "trackEntity2v"..i)
+        trackedEntities[trackEntity2] = { parentId = root }
 
-	        for entityId, info in trackedEntities do
+        -- Removing this, but keeping Animator on the other 2 causes it to stop happening
-	            if world:contains(entityId) and not world:parent(entityId :: any) then
+        world:set(trackEntity1, cts.VelocitizeAnimationWeight, 0)
-	                print(`bugged entity found: {entityId}`)
+
-	                print(`original parent: {info.parentId}`)
+		local q = world:query(jecs.pair(jecs.ChildOf, __)):cached()
-	                print(`batch = {batch}, i = {i}`)
+
-	                print("==========================================")
+
-	                trackedEntities[entityId] = nil
+        world:delete(root)
-					world:delete(entityId)
+
-	            end
+
-	        end
+		for entityId, info in trackedEntities do
-	    end
+            if world:contains(entityId) and not world:parent(entityId :: any) then
-	end
+                print(`bugged entity found: {entityId}`)
+                print(`original parent: {info.parentId}`)
+                print(`current parent: {i}`)
+                print(`batch = {batchSize}, i = {i}`)
+                print("==========================================")
+                trackedEntities[entityId] = nil
+            end
+        end
+        for entity in q do
+			local parent = world:parent(entity) :: jecs.Entity
+			CHECK(world:parent(entity) == nil)
+		end
+    end
 end)
 
 TEST("Ensure archetype edges get cleaned", function()
@@ -980,9 +917,6 @@ TEST("world:delete()", function()
 		CHECK(destroyed)
 		CHECK(not world:contains(child))
 	end
-	if true then
-		return
-	end
 
 	do CASE "Should delete children in different archetypes if they have the same parent"
 		local world = jecs.world()
@@ -1599,12 +1533,10 @@ TEST("world:range()", function()
 	do CASE "spawn entity under min range"
 		local world = jecs.world()
 		world:range(400, 1000)
-		CHECK(world.entity_index.alive_count == 399)
 		local e = world:entity(300)
-		CHECK(world.entity_index.alive_count == 400)
 		local e1 = world:entity(300)
-		CHECK(world.entity_index.alive_count == 400)
+		CHECK(world:contains(e))
-		CHECK(e)
+		CHECK(world:contains(e1))
 	end
 	do CASE "entity ID reuse works correctly across different world ranges"
 		local base = jecs.world()
@@ -1651,6 +1583,7 @@ TEST("world:range()", function()
 		CHECK(bar == bar_mirror)
 	end
 
+	print("<do CASE \"delete outside partitioned range\">")
 	do CASE "delete outside partitioned range"
 		local server = jecs.world()
 		local client = jecs.world()
@@ -1668,8 +1601,25 @@ TEST("world:range()", function()
 		CHECK(client:get(e2, A))
 
 		client:delete(e2)
+
+
+		print("<client.entity_index.max_id>")
+		print(client.entity_index.max_id)
+		print("</client.entity_index.max_id>")
+
+		print("<client.entity_index.alive_count>")
+		print(client.entity_index.alive_count)
+		print("</client.entity_index.alive_count>")
+
+		print("</client.entity_index.dense_array[client.entity_index.alive_count]>")
+		print(client.entity_index.dense_array[client.entity_index.alive_count])
+		print("</client.entity_index.dense_array[client.entity_index.alive_count]>")
+		print("<client:entity()>")
 		local e3 = client:entity()
-		CHECK(ECS_ID(e3) == 1000)
+		print("</client:entity()>")
+		print("<ECS_ID(e3) == 1001>")
+		CHECK(ECS_ID(e3) == 1001)
+		print("</ECS_ID(e3) == 1001>")
 
 		local e1v1 = server:entity()
 		local e4 = client:entity(e1v1)
@@ -1679,6 +1629,281 @@ TEST("world:range()", function()
 		CHECK(client:contains(e4))
 	end
 
+	print("</do CASE \"delete outside partitioned range\">")
+
+	do CASE "desired id within range does not overwrite existing entities"
+		local world = jecs.world()
+		world:range(1000, 2000)
+
+		local ctype = world:component()
+
+		local e1 = world:entity(1000)
+		local e2 = world:entity(1001)
+		local e3 = world:entity(1002)
+
+		world:set(e1, ctype, "entity1")
+		world:set(e2, ctype, "entity2")
+		world:set(e3, ctype, "entity3")
+
+		local e4 = world:entity(1500)
+		world:set(e4, ctype, "entity4")
+
+		CHECK(world:contains(e1))
+		CHECK(world:contains(e2))
+		CHECK(world:contains(e3))
+		CHECK(world:contains(e4))
+		CHECK(world:get(e1, ctype) == "entity1")
+		CHECK(world:get(e2, ctype) == "entity2")
+		CHECK(world:get(e3, ctype) == "entity3")
+		CHECK(world:get(e4, ctype) == "entity4")
+	end
+
+	do CASE "creating entity with range+offset does not conflict with existing"
+		local world = jecs.world()
+		world:range(500, 1000)
+
+		local ctype = world:component()
+
+		local base = world:entity(500)
+		world:set(base, ctype, "base")
+
+		local offset1 = world:entity(501)
+		world:set(offset1, ctype, "offset1")
+
+		local offset2 = world:entity(750)
+		world:set(offset2, ctype, "offset2")
+
+		CHECK(world:contains(base))
+		CHECK(world:contains(offset1))
+		CHECK(world:contains(offset2))
+		CHECK(world:get(base, ctype) == "base")
+		CHECK(world:get(offset1, ctype) == "offset1")
+		CHECK(world:get(offset2, ctype) == "offset2")
+	end
+
+	do CASE "creating entities in reverse order within range"
+		local world = jecs.world()
+		world:range(100, 200)
+
+		local ctype = world:component()
+
+		local e3 = world:entity(150)
+		local e2 = world:entity(120)
+		local e1 = world:entity(110)
+
+		world:set(e1, ctype, 1)
+		world:set(e2, ctype, 2)
+		world:set(e3, ctype, 3)
+
+		-- All should exist independently
+		CHECK(world:contains(e1))
+		CHECK(world:contains(e2))
+		CHECK(world:contains(e3))
+		CHECK(world:get(e1, ctype) == 1)
+		CHECK(world:get(e2, ctype) == 2)
+		CHECK(world:get(e3, ctype) == 3)
+	end
+
+	do CASE "creating entity with desired ID after range pre-population"
+		local world = jecs.world()
+		world:range(400, 1000)
+
+		local ctype = world:component()
+
+		-- Range pre-populates 1-399 with dense=0
+		-- Create an entity at a pre-populated position
+		local e1 = world:entity(300)
+		world:set(e1, ctype, "prepop")
+
+		-- Create another entity at a different pre-populated position
+		local e2 = world:entity(250)
+		world:set(e2, ctype, "prepop2")
+
+		-- Create entity within the range
+		local e3 = world:entity(500)
+		world:set(e3, ctype, "inrange")
+
+		-- All should work correctly
+		CHECK(world:contains(e1))
+		CHECK(world:contains(e2))
+		CHECK(world:contains(e3))
+		CHECK(world:get(e1, ctype) == "prepop")
+		CHECK(world:get(e2, ctype) == "prepop2")
+		CHECK(world:get(e3, ctype) == "inrange")
+	end
+
+	do CASE "creating same entity twice returns existing entity"
+		local world = jecs.world()
+		world:range(1000, 2000)
+
+		local ctype = world:component()
+
+		-- Create entity
+		local e1 = world:entity(1500)
+		world:set(e1, ctype, "original")
+
+		-- Try to create it again
+		local e2 = world:entity(1500)
+
+		-- Should return the same entity
+		CHECK(e1 == e2)
+		CHECK(world:get(e1, ctype) == "original")
+		CHECK(world:get(e2, ctype) == "original")
+
+		-- Should only be one entity
+		local count = 0
+		for _ in world:query(ctype) do
+			count += 1
+		end
+		CHECK(count == 1)
+	end
+
+	do CASE "creating entities with gaps in range does not affect existing"
+		local world = jecs.world()
+		world:range(200, 300)
+
+		local ctype = world:component()
+
+		-- Create entities with gaps
+		local e1 = world:entity(200)
+		local e2 = world:entity(250)
+		local e3 = world:entity(299)
+
+		world:set(e1, ctype, 1)
+		world:set(e2, ctype, 2)
+		world:set(e3, ctype, 3)
+
+		-- Create entity in the gap
+		local e4 = world:entity(225)
+		world:set(e4, ctype, 4)
+
+		-- All should still exist
+		CHECK(world:contains(e1))
+		CHECK(world:contains(e2))
+		CHECK(world:contains(e3))
+		CHECK(world:contains(e4))
+		CHECK(world:get(e1, ctype) == 1)
+		CHECK(world:get(e2, ctype) == 2)
+		CHECK(world:get(e3, ctype) == 3)
+		CHECK(world:get(e4, ctype) == 4)
+	end
+
+	do CASE "creating many entities with desired IDs in range"
+		local world = jecs.world()
+		world:range(1000, 2000)
+
+		local ctype = world:component()
+		local entities = {}
+
+		-- Create 50 entities with specific IDs
+		for i = 1, 50 do
+			local id = 1000 + (i * 10)
+			local e = world:entity(id)
+			world:set(e, ctype, i)
+			entities[i] = e
+		end
+
+		-- Verify all exist and have correct values
+		for i = 1, 50 do
+			CHECK(world:contains(entities[i]))
+			CHECK(world:get(entities[i], ctype) == i)
+		end
+
+		-- Create more entities in between
+		for i = 1, 49 do
+			local id = 1000 + (i * 10) + 5
+			local e = world:entity(id)
+			world:set(e, ctype, i + 100)
+		end
+
+		-- Original entities should still be intact
+		for i = 1, 50 do
+			CHECK(world:contains(entities[i]))
+			CHECK(world:get(entities[i], ctype) == i)
+		end
+	end
+
+	do CASE "sparse_array remains optimized with non-contiguous entity IDs"
+		local world = jecs.world()
+		local ctype = world:component()
+
+		-- Create entities with large gaps to test sparse_array optimization
+		-- Start with entity 100, then jump to 1000 (gap: 101-999)
+		local e1 = world:entity(100)
+		local e2 = world:entity(1000)
+		-- Then jump to 5000 (gap: 1001-4999)
+		local e3 = world:entity(5000)
+		-- Then jump to 10000 (gap: 5001-9999)
+		local e4 = world:entity(10000)
+
+		world:set(e1, ctype, 1)
+		world:set(e2, ctype, 2)
+		world:set(e3, ctype, 3)
+		world:set(e4, ctype, 4)
+
+		-- Verify all entities exist and have correct values
+		CHECK(world:contains(e1))
+		CHECK(world:contains(e2))
+		CHECK(world:contains(e3))
+		CHECK(world:contains(e4))
+		CHECK(world:get(e1, ctype) == 1)
+		CHECK(world:get(e2, ctype) == 2)
+		CHECK(world:get(e3, ctype) == 3)
+		CHECK(world:get(e4, ctype) == 4)
+
+		-- Verify intermediate IDs are pre-populated (they should exist but not be alive)
+		-- These are in the gaps between created entities
+		local sparse_array = world.entity_index.sparse_array
+		CHECK(sparse_array[500] ~= nil) -- Between 100 and 1000, should be pre-populated
+		CHECK(sparse_array[500].dense == 0) -- But not alive (dense=0)
+		CHECK(sparse_array[2500] ~= nil) -- Between 1000 and 5000, should be pre-populated
+		CHECK(sparse_array[2500].dense == 0)
+		CHECK(sparse_array[7500] ~= nil) -- Between 5000 and 10000, should be pre-populated
+		CHECK(sparse_array[7500].dense == 0)
+
+		-- Verify max_id was updated correctly
+		CHECK(world.entity_index.max_id == 10000)
+	end
+	do CASE "desired id does not overwrite old entity id"
+		local world = jecs.world()
+		local ctype = world:component()
+		local id = world:entity()
+
+		print("<local e = world:entity(id + 1)>")
+		local e = world:entity((id::any) + 1)
+		print("</local e = world:entity(id + 1)>")
+
+		CHECK(world:contains(id))
+		CHECK(world:contains(e))
+
+		-- also make sure that they don't share the same record
+
+		world:set(id, ctype, 1)
+		world:set(e, ctype, 2)
+
+		CHECK(world:get(id, ctype) == 1)
+		CHECK(world:get(e, ctype) == 2)
+	end
+
+	do CASE "creating ids with a higher key first"
+		local world = jecs.world()
+		local ctype = world:component()
+
+		local e = world:entity(1000)
+		local id = world:entity(999)
+
+		CHECK(world:contains(id))
+		CHECK(world:contains(e))
+
+		-- also make sure that they don't share the same record
+
+		world:set(id, ctype, 1)
+		world:set(e, ctype, 2)
+
+		CHECK(world:get(id, ctype) == 1)
+		CHECK(world:get(e, ctype) == 2)
+	end
+
 	do CASE "under range start"
 
 		local world = jecs.world()
@@ -1746,6 +1971,45 @@ TEST("world:entity()", function()
 		local e2 = world:entity(399)
 		CHECK(world:contains(e2))
 	end
+
+	do CASE "desired id does not overwrite old entity id"
+		local world = jecs.world()
+		local ctype = world:component()
+		local id = world:entity()
+
+		local e = world:entity((id::any) + 1)
+
+		CHECK(world:contains(id))
+		CHECK(world:contains(e))
+
+		-- also make sure that they don't share the same record
+
+		world:set(id, ctype, 1)
+		world:set(e, ctype, 2)
+
+		CHECK(world:get(id, ctype) == 1)
+		CHECK(world:get(e, ctype) == 2)
+	end
+
+	do CASE "creating ids with a higher key first"
+		local world = jecs.world()
+		local ctype = world:component()
+
+		local e = world:entity(1000)
+		local id = world:entity(999)
+
+		CHECK(world:contains(id))
+		CHECK(world:contains(e))
+
+		-- also make sure that they don't share the same record
+
+		world:set(id, ctype, 1)
+		world:set(e, ctype, 2)
+
+		CHECK(world:get(id, ctype) == 1)
+		CHECK(world:get(e, ctype) == 2)
+	end
+
 	local N = 2^8
 
 	do CASE "unique IDs"
@@ -1817,6 +2081,8 @@ TEST("world:entity()", function()
 		CHECK(ECS_ID(e) == pin)
 		CHECK(ECS_GENERATION(e) == 0)
 	end
+
+
 end)
 
 TEST("world:has()", function()